AFL Round 17 wrap: Brisbane surge, Carlton's seven-game winning streak, and Dangerfield turns back the clock (again)
Round 17 wrap
Photo by Damien Tait / Unsplash
Seven matches across four days. A defending premier making a statement, a Victorian giant hanging on by two points, and a 36-year-old captain who refuses to concede to time. Here is everything that happened in AFL Round 17.
Geelong 101 def. by Brisbane Lions 123 | GMHBA Stadium | Thursday
The question going into Thursday night was whether Brisbane could reproduce the kind of performance that separated them from the field last September. The answer arrived inside 14 minutes and it was emphatic.
The Lions kicked the opening eight goals of the match at GMHBA Stadium — territory that has reliably humbled visiting sides all season — leaving the home crowd in stunned silence and Geelong's coaching staff reaching for the whiteboard before the first quarter was done. Charlie Cameron opened the account within two minutes of the first bounce, and by the time Patrick Dangerfield finally got his hands on the ball to end the drought with Geelong's first goal right before quarter time, the margin was already 37 points.
The second quarter produced one of the great momentum swings of the season. Dangerfield, who at 36 continues to defy the conventional wisdom about ageing and elite sport, kicked three goals in the second term alone. Lachie Neale — deployed by Geelong with Oisin Mullin as his personal escort — worked his way into the game and helped the Cats reel off five unanswered goals. By half-time, Geelong had cut the deficit from 43 points to seven. GMHBA Stadium was alive.
Brisbane answered. In the third quarter, with the contest genuinely up for grabs, the Lions steadied and kicked away, and by the final siren the result was a 22-point victory — 19.9 (123) to 14.17 (101) — that leaves the defending premiers looking very much like the team that will be there at the end of September.
Kai Lohmann finished with five goals, Zac Bailey kicked three before leaving the field with hamstring tightness, and Will Ashcroft and Josh Dunkley controlled the midfield for the best part of 80 minutes. Dangerfield's five goals in a losing side was one of the individual performances of the round.
The result leaves Geelong at 9-8 and entangled in the middle-of-the-ladder logjam. Brisbane, with four consecutive wins, are moving.
Sydney Swans 90 def. Western Bulldogs 55 | SCG | Friday
Sydney have had a more complicated second half of the season than their position on the ladder suggests, but Friday night at the SCG was a return to the efficiency and ruthlessness that won them back-to-back premierships. A 35-point win over the Bulldogs — who came in under-strength and left looking uncertain about their finals credentials — was well within their control from the second quarter onward.
The Swans made six changes from the side that was handled by Brisbane in Round 16, recalling Dane Rampe, Hayden McLean, and Matt Roberts, among others. The new combinations clicked quickly. The Bulldogs, who have now lost four of their past six games, face a difficult stretch run to secure a finals position.
Adelaide Crows 99 def. West Coast Eagles 74 | Optus Stadium | Friday
Adelaide made it four wins in their last five games with a composed 25-point performance at Optus Stadium. The Crows' consistent form in the second half of the season has them pushing hard into the top eight, and Friday's result was a measure of how far this club has come from its position at the start of the year.
West Coast, bottom four and still searching for identity, gave the home crowd very little to celebrate. Adelaide led at every change.
Melbourne 125 def. Hawthorn 90 | UTAS Stadium, Launceston | Saturday
Melbourne made a commanding statement in Launceston, putting 35 points on Hawthorn at UTAS Stadium in a performance of consistent excellence across all four quarters. After a mid-season wobble that cost them two crucial games, the Demons have now won three consecutive matches and are firmly back in the top-eight conversation.
Hawthorn's surprising run of form — they had been one of the season's better stories — came to a grinding halt. The co-captains, James Sicily and Will Newcombe, had rare quiet games, and Melbourne's inside-50 pressure was unrelenting.
GWS Giants 109 def. Fremantle 88 | Manuka Oval, Canberra | Saturday
Fremantle's lead at the top of the AFL ladder came under scrutiny on Saturday afternoon at Manuka Oval, where GWS handed the Dockers their sharpest defeat of the season. A 21-point loss for Fremantle — who were coming off the bye — raised genuine questions about their consistency away from Optus Stadium, where they have been near unbeatable all year.
GWS were committed and physical, and the Canberra crowd gave them vociferous support. For the Giants, who sit in the eight despite limited fanfare, the win confirmed they remain a dangerous proposition for any finals opponent.
Collingwood 104 def. Gold Coast Suns 98 | People First Stadium | Saturday
Nick Daicos was, once again, the difference. Collingwood survived a fierce challenge from Gold Coast at People First Stadium, winning by just six points in a match that went to the final quarter before the result was settled. Gold Coast, missing key personnel and missing their top-eight position after being beaten by the Dockers in Round 16, made Collingwood work for everything they got.
Daicos finished with disposals in the high 30s and multiple score involvements — a stat line that has become almost routine for the game's best young player. The match was also marred by an MRO matter involving Brayden Maynard and Ben Long, the details of which were being reviewed at time of writing.
Carlton 74 def. Richmond 72 | MCG | Saturday night
Two points. Two points at the MCG on a cold Saturday night in July, and Carlton have their seventh consecutive win under caretaker coach Josh Fraser — who was thrown into the role and has not dropped a game since.
The Blues were under serious pressure late. Richmond, whose youth movement has produced genuine highlights across a difficult season, kicked three consecutive goals in the final quarter to close from 12 points down to one point inside the final minute. Seth Campbell had the margin to a kick. Tom Lynch, returning from a larynx fracture, was unable to convert opportunities that might have stolen the result.
George Hewett sealed it for Carlton in what was an extraordinary moment — denying an arm-chop free kick to Harry McKay in a confusing sequence that drew the wrath of the Punt Road faithful, but the two points went to Carlton and Patrick Cripps celebrated with a team that now genuinely believes it can sneak into the top eight from outside the cut.
Fraser's perfect record in the role will generate significant discussion about Carlton's coaching future. Whatever happens there, the Blues are seven from seven under his watch.
Carlton 10.14 (74) def. Richmond 10.12 (72). MCG, Saturday 4 July.
Port Adelaide 73 def. North Melbourne 52 | Adelaide Oval | Sunday Afternoon
St Kilda 117 def. Essendon 50 | Marvel Stadium | Sunday Afternoon
Join the discussion
Have your say. Keep it fair. Read our Community Guidelines before commenting.